Church Discipline: Never Popular, But Always Necessary

image1The Reformed have long held that scripture teaches us that a true church of the Lord Jesus Christ will manifest three definite marks by which all men might know that it is truly a church. The Belgic Confession summed up these three marks this way:

“The marks by which the true Church is known are these: If the pure doctrine of the gospel is preached therein; if it maintains the pure administration of the sacraments as instituted by Christ; if church discipline is exercised in chastening of sin; in short, if all things are managed according to the pure Word of God, all things contrary thereto rejected, and Jesus Christ acknowledged as the only Head of the Church. Hereby the true Church may certainly be known, from which no man has a right to separate himself.” (The Belgic Confession of Faith, Article XXIX )

Now in the present day if we look at the problems of the evangelical churches, we would have to say that gospel preaching is at a low ebb, and there is plenty of anecdotal evidence that the administration of the sacraments has fallen into a sad state in many a church. For instance, I heard one brother say that at one church he visited in California, they served the Lord’s Supper by putting out juice and crackers on tables on the sides of the auditorium and then flashed an invitation for people to take some when they wanted to on the screens up front.

But as badly neglected as the first two marks of the church may be, surely it is the third mark of the true church – the biblical exercise of church discipline – that has fallen into almost total neglect. These days it is becoming hard to find churches that exercise it at all, and generally if you bring up the subject, everyone has a reason for not implementing it. Some of the more common I hear are that times have changed and while it was once possible to expect a standard of faith and practice from members of the church it isn’t any longer, or that if we started to exercise church discipline people would leave the church.

Now regarding the first of these, that times have changed and that it was once easy and now is difficult, I’d say read some church history, church discipline has never been easy or popular as Richard Baxter made clear in his book The Reformed Pastor written in 1656:

My second request to the ministers in these kingdoms is that they would at last, without any more delay, unanimously set themselves to the practice of those parts of Church discipline which are unquestionably necessary, and part of  their work. It is a sad case, that good men should settle themselves so long in the constant neglect of so great a duty. The common cry is, “Our people are not ready for it; they will not bear it.” But is not the fact rather that you will not bear the trouble and hatred which it will occasion? If indeed, you proclaim our churches incapable of the order and government of Christ, what do you do, but give up the cause to them that withdraw from us, and encourage men to look out for better societies, where that discipline may be had? For though preaching and sacraments may be omitted in some cases, till a fitter season, as may discipline also, yet it is a hard case to settle in a constant neglect, for so many years together, as we have done, unless there were an absolute impossibility of the work. And if it were so, because of our incapable materials, it would plainly call us to alter our constitution, that the matter may be capable.

Regarding the idea that it will drive people out, yes it might cause those who are members of the church, but who refuse to obey the commands of Christ to leave, but then again isn’t that merely a separating of wheat from chaff, and one the purposes of church discipline? What do we think happens to a church full of apostates anyway? Do we believe Paul was kidding when he warned “Do you not know that a little leaven leavens the whole lump?” (1 Cor. 5:6)

Sadly in Baxter’s time as in ours, there is plenty of talk and debate in magazines, presbyteries, and conferences about the best way to compassionately implement church discipline, but it’s actual implementation hardly ever seems to occur. This appears to be one form of biblical reformation that churches, regardless of their polity, are loathe to institute. Baxter’s comment on this point seems to be applicable to the church in every age:

Lastly, We are sadly negligent in performing acknowledged duties; for example, church discipline. If there be any work of reformation to be set afoot, how many are there that will go no further than they are drawn! It were well if all would do even that much. And when a work is like to prove difficult and costly, how backward are we to it, and how many excuses do we make for the omission of it! What hath been more talked of, and prayed for, and contended about in England, for many years past, than discipline? There are, in fact, but few men who do not seem zealous in disputing for one side or other; some for the Prelatical way, some for the Presbyterian, and some for the Congregational. And yet, when we come to the practice of it, for aught I see, we are quite agreed: most of us are for no way. It hath made me wonder, sometimes, to look on the face of England, and see how few congregations in the land have any considerable execution of discipline. And to think withal what volumes have been written for it, and how almost all the ministry of the nation are engaged for it. How zealously they have contended for it, and made many a just exclamation against the opposers of it. And yet, notwithstanding all this, they will do little or nothing in the exercise of it. I have marveled what should make them so zealous in siding for that which their practice shows their hearts are against. But I see a disputing zeal is more natural than a holy, obedient, practicing zeal.


About Andrew Webb

I was converted out of paganism and the occult in 1993 and while I was initially Charismatic/Arminian in my theology, I became Reformed and Presbyterian through bible study and the influence of ministries like RC Sproul's. After teaching in local bible studies, and taking seminary courses part time, I began to feel called to the ministry in 1997. I was Ordained as an RE at Christ Covenant PCA in Hatboro, PA in 2000 and as a TE by Central Carolina Presbytery in 2001 when I was called to be the Organizing Pastor/Church Planter for Providence PCA Mission, Cross Creek PCA's church plant in Fayetteville, NC (home to Ft. Bragg and Pope Airforce Base). In 2005 when the Providence PCA Particularized I was blessed to be called by the congregation to be their Pastor
This entry was posted in Church Planting, Ecclesiology. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Church Discipline: Never Popular, But Always Necessary

  1. Kevin says:

    I think Baxter should be required reading for every seminary student. Great post.

  2. Josh says:

    Andy, a friend of mine serves a small baptist church in northeastern NC that is over 150 years old. The membership roll for the first fifty years of its existence includes a column of explanation of why a person was removed from the roll. The primary entry (which appeared for well over 50 names) was “indifference.” These people were removed from church membership because they were careless in their attention to their spiritual exercizes, including church attendance! During this time period, the church ran over 200 in attendance. This was in a sparsely populated rural community. As the entries for dismissals began to fade away, so did the church’s attendance, until today they run about 50.

    I can say from experience that church discipline is challenging. Most of the time the brother is won and their is reconciliation. When a refusal to repent does lead to excommunication it is very painful. But I have seen its sobering effect. It does teach us to fear the treachery of sin in our own lives, when we see the discipline of the Lord through the discipline of the church. I once feared that excommunication would produce pride in the hearts of the church leadership, but I have found the opposite to be the case. Nothing has so humbled leadership in our church as dealing with a member’s sin. There is nothing loving about ignoring sin in a friend’s life, just to keep his affections. The loving thing is to set aside the desire to be adored and address the sin for the sake of his soul, the church’s purity, and the honor of Christ.

  3. I’d like to see some scanned pages from that membership listing of that church Josh!

    You’re right Andy, we talk about this book but we don’t do much. I’ve tried, when visiting hospitals, always to read a Psalm and pray for people instead of just “dropping in” and wasting time only with chit chat, not that some conversation isn’t important too.

    The issue is how to move on to an environment in the body where there is ongoing catechesis from the pulpit and in the homes.

    It’s promising to see churches printing questions from their respective catechisms more in bulletins.. the issue is making those topics of ordinary discourse in the church.

    I’ve linked to a page outlining significant issues in the church and world today and I credit the author for noting this problem:

    “Above all, multitudes of Christians remain captive to the greatest crisis of all. It is a “crisis of Christology”. It is the significant shortfall in how we see, seek, savor, serve, share and speak about God’s Son for ALL that He is. Increasing numbers of spiritual leaders identify this as the seminal crisis for the Church at this hour. But it also comprises the greatest crisis the world is facing whether the world realizes it or not. Every crisis of Christology inside the Church hinders unbelievers outside the Church from discovering their one God-given hope – found in the supremacy of Christ and the blessings of His redeeming Reign.”

    By some estimates, we don’t even talk about the glories of Jesus Christ to one another… “Gossiping the Gospel” was a term I heard used to describe this once.

  4. J.W.M. says:

    Andy, we had to read Baxter for pastoral theology at GPTS. It was an outstanding book. I’d also highly recommend William Blaikie’s _For the Work of the Ministry_.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s